*Update*
The winning bad review, submitted by Janice, was called “Some rooms are Haunted”. Here is the review… plus my commentary:
Now I don’t mean to be insensitive about this crap, but… I just can’t help but notice something.
My wife can see ‘extraordinary’ beings.
Yea. Best opening of any review.
On the 2nd day evening, she started telling me that she sees ‘shadows’ in the room. We traveled 12 years together & this was the 1st time the situation was so intense that she asked to change room due to this kind of reason.
Mmmkkk…
We spoke to the duty manager, he was not very accommodating. He changed us to another room on another floor.
Wait. He wasn’t very accommodating, but he changed you to another room, on another floor? What were you hoping for?
My wife said it was still ‘unclean’. At last, the duty manager found another bigger room but wanted us to pay more for it.
Ahhh. Alas, I see. Different room on a different floor, that wouldn’t help. But a bigger room, that would do it!
I felt unhappy because the problem was with the hotel room. However, it was already very late at night & I didn’t want to argue with him, so I agreed. We changed to the bigger room on another floor.
1 star? He moved you around. He told you the bigger rooms are more expensive, and he moved you (because it’s “unclean”) and you still complained? Wow.
Before the update:
Yes, this is a contest with a prize. But this is about something greater! It’s about a community coming together to find the most epicly dumb hotel TripAdvisor review online!
To participate, you need to share links to dumb TA reviews in the comments below. With many hands we’ll quickly have a page of funny/dumb reviews until we have the absolute most obnoxious/dumb review in existence.
Let me explain
Two days ago I posted about dumb hotel reviews – “Angry About Angries: Epicly Dumb Tripadvisor Reviews“. For whatever reason, I find these dumb reviews hilarious. I know, I need to get out of hotels more often. Anyways, the thought hit me, “how can I get more of these dumb reviews? … a contest!”
Readers! I call upon you to submit the dumbest reviews across TripAdvisor for a prize.
Here’s a picture to show how to get the link and see the number of reviews the reviewer has made before. If you want you can add a quote from the review or reason why it’s dumb/funny. Like, “here’s a review of someone who may be smart enough to find the hotel’s email online… but too dumb to use the booking function. So they left a bad review.”
Contest Rules
- Has to be a hotel review on TripAdvisor.
- The reviewer has to have more than one review. (This is because there are so many reviews that are spam from competitors, which is a bummer). Although, if it was obviously not spam and funny enough knowing that, or just funny enough, I’d take it.
- Review has to be written before this week. In other words it has to have been written May 24th or earlier.
- DO NOT SPAM. Listen, this isn’t a spam contest, leaving tons of comments won’t help. Quality wins here. Quality over quantity. I’m thinking like 5 comments a day is too much. I spent days coming up with these (sad but it’s addicting) and left out 3 others.
Reviews must be submitted by June 10, 2014.
How To Submit
- Take the link of the review itself (as I showed in the picture above).
- Comment below with the link of the review.
–> You can also pull out quotes to help us get right to the humor, irony, or shockingly dumb part of the review. And give us a title of why it’s funny. - Include your email address (it won’t be shown).
- We (or someone) will look through the submissions and pick out our favorites.
- Then we will give the (5?) dumbest reviews for the readers to vote on. Voting will be on June 10, 2014 on travelisfree.com.
Prize
- The winner gets a $100 hotel gift card to the hotel chain of their choice (one of the major brands).
What would be awesome is if I could contact one of the hotels to see if they would sponsor by giving a prize. So stay tuned and check back here… both for potentional prize updates and for funny reviews.
* Rules and details are based on whatever I want and could change if I have a reason.
Even if you don’t care about the prize, you should do this to help entertain and teach TA etiquette.
Conclusion
This is an attempt to create something hilarious. If you prefer I just have one boring page with 1,000 comments to enter… whatever, maybe I’ll do that next time. If you’d rather support this hilarious contest, please share this contest.
Let the games begin
Start by commenting below!
Piecing our rooms together to create one perfect room at a HoJo.
You can’t make that stuff up. 6 trips back and forth switching out appliances. Man, I’m glad I have hotel points…
Thanks for starting.
and ftr, the link is http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g46715-d92526-r182962927-Howard_Johnson_Express_Inn_Parsippany-Parsippany_New_Jersey.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
Hey Drew:
Just wanted to drop you a line to let you know how much I’ve enjoyed reading about Carrie and your travel life.
Reading other blogs has been turning my stomach as of late. The grand majority of them seem to be thin fronts for douchey credit card hawking sleezebag a-holes. I hope you do ok with your blog despite not taking this slant.
Anyways, you have a new fan. And the next time I go looking for a card it will for sure be from your tasteful links!
Best,
RT
I was an establishment here in SF that had some of their 1-star reviews printed up on their servers’ uniforms. It got me thinking… Somebody should curate a book of these, yeah? With the right marketing you could create a franchise out of them!
Wait, that’s interesting but I’m not sure I get it.
Did they print them to like shame the servers? Or to mock the reviews? Or just to show they don’t give a dern?
Hipsters mocking their Yelp reviews…
“The food was the best I ever tasted, but I had to wait five minutes to order. Because there was another table seated at the same time as me…ONE STAR”
Hipsters mock anything they can.
Wow this contest is great because there is so much ‘good’ material out there.
Holiday Inn Burlington Ontario – Complains that it should be low end and have free breakfast, also that it should be high end and not have spiders everywhere. Come on, you cant have both!
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g154984-d181964-r181500616-Holiday_Inn_Burlington_Hotel_Conference_Centre-Burlington_Ontario.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
This complaint is the definition of first world problems. I don’t know what’s worse some idiot complaining about the hotel not providing him a iphone charger or the GM actually apologizing. http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g52024-d96154-r179927055-The_Heathman_Hotel-Portland_Oregon.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
The title of this one says it all…”We never stayed here!”
*After reading the review, I think the hotel should have received 5 stars.
TripAdvisor Link: http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g190441-d237762-r183380778-Stadtkrug_Hotel-Salzburg_Austrian_Alps.html#UR183380778
This may not be relevant to most of your readers but as someone devoted to eco-tourism it gave me a chuckle. This is one of the world’s great eco lodges and famous for the bird watching so I don’t know why this person went there. Maybe he was expecting elephants & lions? LOL This person was there a month before we were and I saw no sign of wasps and the bathrooms were fine, had hot water so what more do you want in the middle of the jungle?
“The website promises encounters with wild animals, but the only ones we saw during our 5 day stay were birds and monkeys. Getting up at 6 in the morning (to avoid the heat) and then looking for birds at a great distance with a group of 7 people and one pair of binoculars gets really boring after a while.”
http://www.tripadvisor.com.au/ShowUserReviews-g635726-d619273-r155060702-Cristalino_Jungle_Lodge-Alta_Floresta_State_of_Mato_Gross.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
OK: I happened to come across this comment today which I thought was hilarious — it’s not about a hotel, though. This reviewer trashes the whole darn population of this beach town:
Mags504
Baltimore, Maryland
posts: 3
“10. Re: Wildwood rundown?
Aug 19, 2013, 6:01 PM
I cannot recommend wildwood, nj to anyone. I was there this weekend for a event, and found the people I encountered to be universally rude and frankly trashy. I had two cars cut me off at a local wawa. One man and his child crossed the street in front of my moving car, and he turned and gave me the finger, WITH HIS CHILD next to him. I encountered several locals at a Walgreens, and was appalled by their rudeness, as they ate food from a McDonald’s and left their trash in the magazine rack by the check out. Who does this sort of thing? And those are just small examples. We had someone break the side mirror of our rental car, the repair was costly and we were told it looked like some one punched it….
I was there for three days and was absolutely shocked to see such behavior. I don’t know why because wildwood is visually a nice town, but the people there made it a place I couldn’t leave fast enough.
There are much much nicer shore points in New jersey than this dump.”
I know that this does not qualify because the reviewer has one review, but it does tell you not to post a bad review until you leave the hotel:
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g482941-d626413-r207284678-Mystique-Oia_Santorini_Cyclades.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
The review was posted while the reviewer was still in the hotel. The owner of the hotel then evicted the reviewer out of the hotel.
http://www.flyertalk.com/forum/starwood-starwood-preferred-guest/1580995-how-low-spg-can-go-issues-stay-mystique-greece.html
I found this on Agoda for the Radisson Blu Bangkok.
“There are two big cockroaches in the toilet . They came from no where and I found it face to face at my toilet when I woke up in the morning. That is the most scary hotel I have ever been.”
I guess being face to face in the toilet after a night in Bangkok isn’t so unusual 😉
I know it doesn’t qualify since it is their only review, but I still like it…
Didn’t stay at the hotel, may not have even entered the actual hotel and admits that they did not read the sign, but still gave the hotel 1 star.
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g60982-d114008-r144187800-The_Kahala_Hotel_Resort-Honolulu_Oahu_Hawaii.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
This traveler is horrified by the “unDisney-like” experience of having to ask for regular coffee and having bus transportation that does not contain sparkles.
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g34515-d120307-r131690617-Disney_s_Coronado_Springs_Resort-Orlando_Florida.html
This may not fit your criteria but it is my favorite Hotel review on Tripadvisor. And I actually stayed at the same hotel, for a work function where I did not get to choose the hotel. My room was better than the one reviewed:
I give you “Room that smelt like a festival toilet!!”
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g188590-d194317-r70926552-NH_City_Centre_Amsterdam-Amsterdam_North_Holland_Province.html
Anyone for a stay at the “Incontinence Hotel”? http://www.tripadvisor.com.au/ShowUserReviews-g659070-d258011-r206903753-InterContinental_Sanctuary_Cove_Resort-Hope_Island_Gold_Coast_Queenslan.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
Oh, the irony! A one-star review (‘Terrible’) because the wifi needed for real-time bragging to friends and family on social media about how great the hotel is was too expensive. It’s not often a one-star review starts “This hotel is beyond beautiful. It is one of the top rated and nicest hotels in the world. I really had a nice time when I stayed here during my honeymoon in French Polynesia…”. http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g311415-d596139-r119227409-InterContinental_Thalasso_Spa_Bora_Bora-Bora_Bora_Society_Islands.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
“Ther is a water on the side and it will cost me 3.5 if i drink it.”
CP executive park at Charlotte is one of the best cp I stayed at, platinums gets access to the lounge.
http://www.tripadvisor.ca/ShowUserReviews-g49022-d94166-r184699004-Crowne_Plaza_Charlotte_Executive_Park-Charlotte_North_Carolina.html#readReview
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g34352-d2336339-r206552237-Disney_s_Art_of_Animation_Resort-Kissimmee_Florida.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
“Went to Space Mountain on this day and a young girl named Michelle, yelled at my daughter to get off the ride.”
Here is a funny one: toxic fumes
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g187069-d659248-r142812936-Macdonald_Manchester_Hotel_Spa-Manchester_Greater_Manchester_England.html
One star rating because beds are hard (despite glowing review of the hotel). He also comments on the “good windows”.
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g60750-d482154-r163026182-Hotel_Solamar_a_Kimpton_Hotel-San_Diego_California.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
Apparently the beach was too sandy.
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g60678-d2075296-r138954350-Tumon_Beach-Tumon_Guam.html
AlexScrivenor, Owner at Crags Hotel, responded to this review, April 2, 2012
However I am happy that you found my wife friendly… I rarely see that side of her! I will pass on your compliments. Maybe that is why we earned two stars instead of one!
In order to seek clarity I suggest you go to YouTube and type in “Spitfire Sounds” there are a number of videos that show MK19 Spitfires in action. I think you will agree that they do not sound like my toilet.
Don’t get me wrong… I am not defending my toilet… it does not make a nice noise. But do you know? In all my puff I have never heard a flushing toilet that made me lie back in bed, slip my weary fins behind my head and think “aaaaah nice!”
If you disagree with anything that I have written then I would be only too pleased to offering you lodgings once again (not free of charge, mind you!) and we can sit in the toilet together and thrash it out!
With reference to your comments about my lavatory… I have researched this issue and find that you are mistaken!
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g190803-d1026930-r126959725-Crags_Hotel-Callander_Loch_Lomond_and_The_Trossachs_National_Park_Scotland.html
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g187147-d250928-r142065497-Park_Hyatt_Paris_Vendome-Paris_Ile_de_France.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
I’ve read that the hotel does not allow pets. What is the European Animal smell? It was beyond disappointing he says. lol
GHOSTS WERE TOO ANNOTING, DIDN’T LET ME SLEEP
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g60880-d73022-r191227925-Sheraton_Anchorage_Hotel-Anchorage_Alaska.html
SORRY FOR THE TYPO
ANNOYING
TOO MANY MEXICANS, THEY SHOULD GO BACK TO THEIR COUNTRY AND NOT BE HERE IN IXTAPA/ZIHUATANEJO
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g153445-d185426-r14261109-Hotel_Fontan_Ixtapa-Ixtapa_Zihuatanejo_Pacific_Coast.html
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g34515-d189076-r159062535-Disney_s_Animal_Kingdom_Lodge-Orlando_Florida.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
“The worst hotel I’ve ever stayed in”
because…
“For a five star Luxury hotel I expected a minibar – this was empty.” DUMB
… and ….
“I do not expect to have to wait in a queue to get a table for breakfast.” DUMBER
This person goes on to complain about the way her children were treated, but also observes, “… all children I saw during the week were impeccably well behaved.” Perhaps we’ve found the problem here – DUMBEST!
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g60982-d114024-r53617429-The_Royal_Hawaiian_a_Luxury_Collection_Resort-Honolulu_Oahu_Hawaii.html
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g60763-d93614-r166195063-The_St_Regis_New_York-New_York_City_New_York.html
I – a Starwood Gold Member could not get the St. Regis to send a free limo to pick me up from a restaurant because it was raining.
Oh, the humanity!
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g1066460-d304546-r146432601-Hotel_Metropolitan_Tokyo-Toshima_Tokyo_Tokyo_Prefecture_Kanto.html
“My wife can see ‘extraordinary’ beings…”
Yes, this guy asked them to change his room because it was ‘haunted’, according to his wife. And they actually gave him a different room on a different floor, but his wife was still unhappy with it. So they offered him a larger room, but wanted him to pay more for it! HOW UNREASONABLE OF THEM! SURELY THEY DESERVE THAT ONE STAR!
I know you probably wouldn’t stay here because of your “beliefs”, but I actually find this hotel quite comforting. #astronomy #equalrights #drewhatesspace
http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g31170-d899759-Reviews-Astronomers_Inn-Benson_Arizona.html
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g60982-d114031-r197336618-Holiday_Inn_Waikiki_Beachcomber_Resort_Hotel-Honolulu_Oahu_Hawaii.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
The horror – no glass cups and rooms service at a Holiday Inn!
Learning to translate weird traveler’s language into english
– the manager is too pushy and took way too much interest in me as a woman–
Translation—I wanted to pay 1 day but stay 2 and also have a Taxi driver wait for me for 2 hours and then say no but the manager didn’t let me get away with it .
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g297666-d4232257-r200088499-Jamna_Vilas_Guest_House-Bikaner_Rajasthan.html
I hate people like these, who try to get free stuff and take advantage of a situation/poor people and then when they don’t get away with it, they drum up things like “unsafe for single women”.. ridiculous.. if the manager talks to you nicely, then he is a perv, if he doesn’t talk to you nicely, he is rude.. there is just no winning with some people..
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g6351830-d302789-r7569966-Al_Maha_Desert_Resort-Murqquab_Emirate_of_Dubai.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
This guy takes sarcasm in a foreign accent to a whole new level!
“a guide introduces himself and tells you straight away about excursions like horse riding,camels,nature etc and then asks you if ur interested…for god sake,i am just after getting out of a car after a long drive,all i want to do is get to the villa and not speak to crocodile dundee yet.” hahahha that got me rolling. Crocodile Dundee in Dubai.
“here comes a SAND STORM,so we bailed in doors,40 mins later,the whold place was thick with sand…nothing to worry about babe….they will send someone up to clean up the place…………” Of course, they have the sandstorm cleaning crew.
Best quote of the review, his dad’s an undertaker!!
“most tables were full but no one was making a sound…as my father is an undertaker,there was more nice in one of his parlours i was thinking…..”
I think I really found a gem on this one.
I liked this part of this review:
“no privacy (guests must pass eachother’s rooms in order to go to and fro);”
Maybe I’m misunderstanding, but does a place even exist where you don’t walk by the entrance to other rooms?!
http://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g150813-d557443-r12304210-Mezzanine_Hotel-Tulum_Yucatan_Peninsula.html#CHECK_RATES_CONT
(I know I’m a day late, but just wanted to share the ridiculousness!)
this could be the worst hotel review ever:
http://www.stltoday.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/jurors-acquit-man-of-molesting-girl-at-ritz-carlton-in/article_7cf7979a-d11f-561a-9eed-96828db515b4.html